We have affiliate relationships with some of the companies featured here. Read full disclosure here.
Casper Mattress vs Top 5 Mattresses 2021
Updated: January 2020
We Tested the Casper Mattress & Others
Looking for a comfortable and affordable mattress? Our researchers have bought and tested some of 2021’s most popular mattresses such as the Casper Mattress, Comfy, and Saatva, and here’s our ranking of the best ones based on things such as comfort and support, price, length of warranty, trial period, and of course overall value:
Best Mattresses 2021
Our Score: 9.9
Our Score: 9.2
$799
Queen Size Price
$1,095
Lifetime Warranty
2 FREE Pillows ($80 value)
BeCool Cooling Layer
Transparent Pricing
Free, No Contact Delivery
150-Night Sleep Trial
Trial Period
100-Night Sleep Trial
10/10
Comfort & Support
8.5/10
9/10
Edge Support
9/10
10/10
Sleeping Cool
8.5/10
Casper vs Comfy: Construction
BeCool Cooling Layer
Extra-Breathable Transition Layer
Support Foam Base
Airscape™ breathable foam
Zoned Support™ layer
Support foam base
Casper vs Comfy: Comfort & Support
Comfy's BeCool cooling layer sleeps cool
Best-in-class support & comfort
Great for all sleepers (side, back & stomach)
Comfortable sleep even without a pillow
Not the most comfortable mattress we tested
Foam feels a little too rigid & bouncy
3 zones of support
Perforated breathable foam
Casper vs Comfy: Temperature Control
"Sleeping Cool" score: 10/10
BeCool cooling layer
Cooling mattress cover
"Sleeping Cool" score: 8.5/10
Not the coolest mattress we tested
Perforated breathable foam
Casper vs Comfy: Motion Transfer
Both mattresses kept motion transfer to a minimum
This means that you will not be disturbed by your partner’s movement when they turn, toss, or get out of bed during the night.
Casper vs Comfy: Edge Support
Great support in the center
Good support around the edges
Minimum motion transfer
Good support in the center
Good support around the edges
Overall edge support is good
Casper vs Comfy: Weight & Size
Lighter than Casper Mattress
Queen Comfy mattress weighs around 58 pounds
About the same size as Casper
The Queen Casper Mattress weighs around 85 pounds
Heavier than Comfy (85 pounds vs Comfy's 58)
About the same size as Comfy
Our Top Pick
BEST OVERALL: Comfy Mattress
Our Score: 9.9
BEST OVERALL:
Comfy Mattress
Lifetime Warranty
No-Risk 150-Night Trial
BeCool Cooling Layer
Great for All Sleep Positions
Great Comfort & Support
Uses Only CertiPUR-US® Certified Foam
Get $400 OFF + 2 FREE Pillows
FREE, No-Contact Delivery
Made in the USA