Casper Mattress vs Top 5 Mattresses 2020

Updated: November 2020

We Tested the Casper Mattress & Others

Looking for a comfortable and affordable mattress? Our researchers have bought and tested some of 2020’s most popular mattresses such as the Casper Mattress, Comfy, and Saatva, and here’s our ranking of the best ones based on things such as comfort and support, price, length of warranty, trial period, and of course overall value:

9.6

"Great"

SHOP NOW
MOST POPULAR

9.9

"Excellent"

SHOP NOW

9.2

"Good"

SHOP NOW

Best Mattresses 2020

Mattress
Score ?
We use scores to help you make an informed decision online. Our scores are based on several different pieces of objective and easily verifiable information - see our How We Rank page for more info. Using our service is 100% free and we receive monetary compensation from some of the brands listed on the site.
Features We Like
MOST POPULAR
9.9
Black Friday Sale: $400 OFF + 2 FREE Pillows + Bed Frame For Only $20.21
BeCool Cooling Layer
Great Comfort, Support & Cooling
Lifetime Warranty
150 Night No-Risk Trial
9.6
A+ BBB Rating
Affordable Luxury Mattress
120-Night Risk Free Trial
Good Price for the Quality
9.5
Minimum Motion Transfer
100-Night Sleep Trial
Provides Good Comfort for Most Sleepers
9.2
100-Night Sleep Trial
Good Edge Support
Great Customer Service
9.1
Smart Comfort Grid Tech
Good at Adapting to Your Body
Smart Comfort is Good for Cooling
Casper Mattress vs Our #1 Pick
See Which Mattress Has the Edge
Our Score: 9.9
$400 OFF + 2 FREE PILLOWS
SHOP NOW
Our Score: 9.2
15% OFF Any Mattress
SHOP NOW

$799

Queen Size Price

$1,095

Lifetime Warranty

2 FREE Pillows ($80 value)

BeCool Cooling Layer

Transparent Pricing

Free, No Contact Delivery

150-Night Sleep Trial

Trial Period

100-Night Sleep Trial

10/10

Comfort & Support

8.5/10

9/10

Edge Support

9/10

10/10

Sleeping Cool

8.5/10

Casper vs Comfy: Price

$400 OFF + 2 FREE PILLOWS
15% OFF Any Mattress

Casper vs Comfy: Construction

1

BeCool Cooling Layer

2

Extra-Breathable Transition Layer

3

Support Foam Base

1

Airscape™ breathable foam

2

Zoned Support™ layer

3

Support foam base

Casper vs Comfy: Comfort & Support

1

Comfy's BeCool cooling layer sleeps cool

2

Best-in-class support & comfort

3

Great for all sleepers (side, back & stomach)

4

Comfortable sleep even without a pillow

1

Not the most comfortable mattress we tested

2

Foam feels a little too rigid & bouncy

3

3 zones of support

4

Perforated breathable foam

Casper vs Comfy: Temperature Control

1

"Sleeping Cool" score: 10/10

2

BeCool cooling layer

3

Cooling mattress cover

1

"Sleeping Cool" score: 8.5/10

2

Not the coolest mattress we tested

3

Perforated breathable foam

Casper vs Comfy: Motion Transfer

Both mattresses kept motion transfer to a minimum
This means that you will not be disturbed by your partner’s movement when they turn, toss, or get out of bed during the night.

Casper vs Comfy: Edge Support

1

Great support in the center

2

Good support around the edges

3

Minimum motion transfer

1

Good support in the center

2

Good support around the edges

3

Overall edge support is good

Casper vs Comfy: Weight & Size

1

Lighter than Casper Mattress

2

Queen Comfy mattress weighs around 58 pounds

3

About the same size as Casper

1

The Queen Casper Mattress weighs around 85 pounds

2

Heavier than Comfy (85 pounds vs Comfy's 58)

3

About the same size as Comfy


Our Top Pick

BEST OVERALL: Comfy Mattress

Our Score: 9.9
BEST OVERALL:
Comfy Mattress

Lifetime Warranty

No-Risk 150-Night Trial

BeCool Cooling Layer

Great for All Sleep Positions

Great Comfort & Support

Uses Only CertiPUR-US® Certified Foam

Get $400 OFF + 2 FREE Pillows

FREE, No-Contact Delivery

Made in the USA

$400 OFF + 2 FREE Pillows
SHOP NOW
Click Here to Get Your $400 OFF and 2 FREE Pillows!